Hi! So, for the finale of this three-part series in celebration of Olivia Rodrigo's belated 22nd birthday, I decided to do a post that I've been wanting to do for a while now: a complete ranking of all 41 Olivia Rodrigo songs. Since this is my first time ranking every song by an artist, I have a lot of disclaimers to get out of the way. For one, as always, this is subjective, and some of my choices are probably somewhat controversial, but I don't want to wake up with 8 trillion comments saying "you are cancelled". Also, Olivia Rodrigo has way more than these 41 songs, so here's a quick rundown of what's included and what's not.
What I included:
- Every song on Sour
- Every song on Guts, both the main edition and the (spilled) edition
- Original songs that Olivia sings for High School Musical: The Musical: The Series
- Other released non-album songs by Olivia
What I didn't include:
- Unreleased songs
- Covers
- Remixes or other alternate versions of existing songs
- Bizaardvark soundtrack songs (many of these are great by the way, but they're really not meant as "proper songs" so it wouldn't be fair to include them)
Also, I'm color coding the ranking. The color code has no correlation to how much I like the songs: it's based on what album they come from.
Blue = Sour
Purple = Guts
White = non-album
Finally, I'm splitting the songs into tiers, using Olivia Rodrigo lyrics to name them. Alright, without further ado, let's get into this special ranking!
Dude nice try (2/5 - they have their redeeming qualities, but overall they're not very good):
#41: Youth Actors Conservatory Alma Mater - Since numerous songs on Guts grew on me significantly, Olivia Rodrigo has no songs that I think of as truly bad, but this was the one I had to choose for last place. It's admittedly a cool concept to have Olivia sing an acoustic ballad version of this HSMTMTS alma mater, but it feels inauthentic and honestly kinda boring at times. Also, it's only one minute long. I wasn't sure whether to include this or not, but it technically meets the criteria, so I did.
#40: Girl I've Always Been - My choice for her lowest-ranked album song. This has some nice lyrics, and the production is fine? But I really cannot get into this vocal stylization. I don't think it sounds like Olivia, which is primarily why I don't like to listen to this song.
A stranger I know everything about (3/5 - not great, not bad, just existent):
#39: Baby Is You - Yes, I'm counting this one. Since it was technically "released" even though it was just a snippet from the credits of the movie Driving Home 2 U, it meets the criteria of "other released non-album songs by Olivia". The version I'm ranking is not the full unreleased version: this is the minute-long phone-recorded snippet from the credits, so naturally it can't be very high up, but I would love it if she released a full version of it.
#38: Granted - This is one of those songs where a longer, updated version separate from HSMTMTS might be better.
#37: Bad Idea Right - My "least favorite" song across the main album editions, and also my least favorite single from Olivia Rodrigo. I don't really think this had to be a single. It's fun, it's cute, it's just far from one of Olivia's best works.
#36: Wondering (with Julia Lester) - A nice little ballad, but extremely forgettable in the grand scheme of things.
#35: Just For A Moment (with Joshua Bassett) - Major plot moment and some strong vocals, but there's not much to it outside the show.
Ur ok (4/5 - songs I like but don't willingly come back to very often):
#34: Born To Be Brave (with Dara Renee) - Fun song with a good message.
#33: Brutal - My "least favorite" song on Sour. The way it's written is very creative, but at times somewhat distracting.
#32: Obsessed - The first bonus track I heard, since it was on my edition of the album, and she performed it on the Guts tour before the (spilled) edition was released. The song that leaves us all wondering what her boyfriend's ex's star sign and blood type are.
#31: Even When / The Best Part (with Joshua Bassett) - Really cool concept to have Nini & Ricky write two songs that mash up together. I like Olivia's part significantly more though.
#30: All American Bitch - I stand by my theory that this song is a list of things Olivia tells herself whenever she feels like everything she describes in Brutal. Olivia's two opening tracks are two sides of the same coin.
#29: The Grudge - My opinions on either side of the Taylivia feud songs are naturally kinda biased. Let's just pretend the only song either one of them wrote about each other is Taylor Swift's Clara Bow...
#28: Love Is Embarrassing - The title alone is relatable, but the choice to sing like a 50s Broadway star in the bridge baffles me to this day.
#27: Second Chance (with Joshua Bassett, Matt Cornett, and Sofia Wylie) - I guess this was a nice moment for all four of these characters in HSMTMTS.
#26: I Think I Kinda, You Know (with Joshua Bassett) - So cute.
#25: Jealousy, Jealousy - This has faded on me slightly, as the "jealousy" concept was much improved by Pretty Isn't Pretty. But it's still a good song with an all too relatable concept at its core.
#24: So American - I have a random theory about the second verse of this song: she changes the pronouns from "he" to "you", which makes me think she's singing about a different person there. According to my interpretation, "he" refers to Louis, her current boyfriend, and "you" refers to her exes who did her wrong, so this song is about showing her exes that she's found someone who makes her happier. "God, I'm so boring, and I'm so rude / Can't have a conversation if it's not all about you" would mean she's "boring" and "rude" for talking to Louis about her exes who did her wrong. "The way you dress and the books you read" would therefore be an insult, like "you have no taste in fashion or books compared to Louis". Just a thought :}
I might just be in lo-lo-lo-lo-lo-lo-lo-lo-lo-lo-lo-love (5/5 - great songs I listen to frequently):
#23: Making The Bed - Doesn't everyone have those moments where it's you who's been making the bed?
#22: Pretty Isn't Pretty - She's feeling twenty-twoooooo, and conveniently the song in this placement is about something we can all probably relate to All Too Well (22 Minute Version) (Olivia's Version).
#21: Out Of The Old - Underrated HSMTMTS gem.
#20: Enough For You - Omg she sang this on the moon.
#19: The Rose Song - One of Liv's earliest moments where her songwriting is on full display.
#18: Traitor - He didn't cheat, but he's still a traitor.
#17: All I Want - Very popular opinion: this is the best song from HSMTMTS.
#16: Scared Of My Guitar - I wouldn't be scared of her guitar.
#15: Stranger - Essentially Olivia's version of the magnificent Clean by Taylor Swift, and my favorite Guts (spilled) bonus track.
#14: Happier - I love the story behind this song, which she explained on the Guts tour, about how she wrote it on a bathroom break between takes on HSMTMTS. Never thought I'd say this, but I hope she writes more songs in the bathroom.
#13: 1 Step Foward, 3 Steps Back - The one song that she got permission to sample a Taylor Swift song on is conveniently placed at lucky 13. I honestly like this quite a bit more than New Years Day, the Taylor song that this interpolates.
#12: Drivers License - Who could ever forget this song? The Olivia Rodrigo song, her debut single, which broke tons of records, and was literally everywhere in 2021. And it was never a single bit overplayed.
#11: Get Him Back - I'll recycle what I said in my water analysis from yesterday: she could either get him back, or she could G E T H I M B A C K .
#10: Deja Vu - On the drive to the Olivia Rodrigo concert, I was listening to Olivia Rodrigo on shuffle, and I cannot tell you how many times this song played. Let's just say I had deja vu every time I heard it.
#9: Logical - The sky. The grass. Iykyk.
#8: Hope Ur Ok - Olivia's most narrative song with a very Swiftian writing style. I kinda want her to write more songs in this style, and I'm sure she will.
#7: Favorite Crime - I love how she captures the excitement and the toxicity of the relationship in such simplistic lyrics.
#6: Ballad Of A Homeschooled Girl - Love Is Embarrassing walked so Ballad Of A Homeschooled Girl could break a glass and trip and fall, tell secrets it shouldn't tell, stumble over all its words, make it weird, make it worse, and make it better.
#5: Lacy - One of this album's biggest growers that I think is about Sabrina Carpenter.
#4: Good 4 U - Already an absolute classic in Olivia's catalog, and a rare case of a major radio single being my favorite song on an album. Every song on Sour has now been eliminated.
#3: Can't Catch Me Now - My favorite non-album song from Olivia by a long shot. She's here, she's there, she's everywhere. Every non-album song has now been eliminated, so Guts is the only album left.
Cuts right through to my heart (6/5 - an extremely special song):
#2: Vampire - Another rare single choice that I think is absolutely amazing, enough to get the elusive 6/5 rating. Easily my favorite single by Olivia Rodrigo, and one of my favorite singles by anyone. The evolution, the lyrics, the power... it's the type of song we need so much more of!!! But what if I told you there's one song that's even higher ranked than this? Yeah, you all know what #1 is...
Aren't you the greatest thing to ever exist? (10/5 - my second-favorite song of all time!!!!!!!!!!):
#1: Teenage Dream - There will be no further explanation. With Guts finally being eliminated, that concludes my ranking.
Happy 22 to Olivia Rodrigo again! That's all for now! Byeeeeeeeeee!